Dating and Relationship Anxiety Therapy NYC
Dating should not feel like something you have to survive.
You want a connection. But somewhere between the first text and the third date, anxiety takes over. You overanalyze every message, brace yourself for rejection before it even happens, and wonder why something that is supposed to feel exciting mostly feels hard. Dating anxiety is incredibly common, especially in a city like New York, where the options feel endless, but a genuine connection can feel rare. Therapy for dating anxiety can help you understand what is getting in the way and how actually to show up for the relationships you want.
Does this sound like you?
You feel a knot in your stomach every time you open a dating app
You replay conversations and convince yourself you said something wrong
You pull away or self-sabotage when things start to feel real
You have been told you are too much, too intense, or too anxious in relationships
The idea of being truly known by someone feels exciting and terrifying at the same time
You have wondered if your anxiety is the reason things never seem to work out
You keep dating people who feel familiar, even when familiar does not feel good
What's actually going on
Dating anxiety is not a personality flaw, and it is not proof that you are unlovable. It is usually a signal that some part of you learned, at some point, that closeness was not entirely safe. Maybe relationships in your past involved inconsistency, rejection, or hurt. Maybe you grew up in an environment where love felt conditional. Maybe you have just been disappointed enough times that your nervous system has started treating new connections like potential threats.
In New York City, the dating landscape adds its own layer. The paradox of choice, the ghosting, the pace, the pressure to seem effortlessly available while also being appropriately guarded. It is genuinely a lot. And when you already carry anxiety into that environment, dating can start to feel like a full-time job you never applied for.
What most people do not realize is that dating anxiety often has very little to do with the person you are dating. It has everything to do with what you believe about yourself and what you expect to come. That is exactly what therapy can help you work through.
How we work with dating anxiety at On Par Therapy
At On Par Therapy NYC, we do not just help you manage nerves before a first date. We help you understand the deeper patterns that keep anxiety showing up in your romantic life, so you can build relationships that actually feel safe and good.
Psychodynamic therapy is especially useful here, because dating anxiety almost always has roots in earlier relationships and attachment patterns. Understanding where your relational blueprint came from is often the key to rewriting it. CBT helps you identify and challenge the specific thoughts that feed your dating anxiety, things like "if they do not text back quickly it means they are not interested" or "I always ruin things when they get serious." Mindfulness helps you stay present on a date instead of spiraling inside your own head. And DBT gives you practical tools for managing the emotional intensity that can come up when you are feeling vulnerable with someone new.
We work with women navigating early dating anxiety, anxiety within established relationships, and everything in between.
FAQ’s
-
They overlap but they are not the same thing. Social anxiety is a broader discomfort in social situations generally. Dating anxiety is more specifically tied to romantic vulnerability, the fear of rejection, intimacy, or being truly seen by a partner. You can have one without the other, though many people experience both.
-
Pushing through without understanding what is underneath usually just means carrying the same patterns into every new relationship. Therapy helps you get to the root of it so that dating stops feeling like something you are white-knuckling your way through.
-
This comes up a lot in sessions. Timing, language, and how much to share early on are all things we can work through together. Therapy gives you a space to figure out your own story before you try to tell it to someone else.
-
Yes. Anxiety does not disappear once you are in a relationship. For many women it just shifts shape, showing up as fear of abandonment, difficulty trusting, or conflict avoidance. We work with all of it.
-
Possibly, yes. A lot depends on whether the previous therapy addressed the relational and attachment patterns underneath the anxiety, or just the surface symptoms. We would love to talk through what you have tried and where you still feel stuck.
What High-Achieving Women Say About Our Work Together
About Brianna Paruolo, LMHC
Featured as an expert in
I provide virtual therapy for women in New York, New Jersey, South Carolina, Massachusetts and Florida.
CLINICAL EXPERTISE & CREDENTIALS
As founder and Clinical Director of On Par Therapy NYC, I bring elite training and specialized certification to your therapeutic journey:
Advanced Education
Master's Degree in Clinical Mental Health Counseling, St. John's University
Bachelor's Degree in Psychology, St. John's University
President of Chi Sigma Iota Counseling Academic and Professional Honor Society
Specialized Certifications
Certified Narcissistic Abuse Treatment Clinician (NATC)
SBIRT Certified
Psychological First Aid (PFA) Certified
Clinical Experience
Former Primary Therapist at one of the nation's leading eating disorder residential treatment centers
Clinical training in integrative psychotherapy, incorporating innovative approaches including play therapy, biofeedback, and neurofeedback
Featured mental health expert in major media publications and news outlets
On Par Therapy exists because I needed it myself. Before becoming a therapist, I managed social media strategy for health and wellness brands, then transitioned to a People & Culture role at a unicorn startup while pursuing my master's degree.
I understand perfectionism, burnout, and self-doubt not just clinically, but personally. This unique perspective has led major news outlets and publications to tap me as a mental health specialist, providing insights on everything from workplace stress and impostor syndrome to dating dynamics and narcissism.
My practice focuses on the challenges high-achieving women face most: the anxiety that never fully quiets, the perfectionism that both drives and exhausts you, disruptive life transitions, and relationship patterns that feel frustratingly familiar. I integrate CBT, DBT, mindfulness, and relational therapy with a real-world understanding of what it takes to excel without self-destructing.
Therapy with me feels grounded and intelligent, and I like speaking with someone who genuinely gets it because I've sat on both sides of the conversation.
You deserve a relationship that feels like a safe place, not a source of dread.
Book your FREE 15-minute consultation today.
You've achieved success by trusting your instincts. If something is telling you it's time for support that matches your ambition, listen to that voice.
During our complimentary consultation, we'll discuss:
Your current challenges
How my approach aligns with your goals
Practical next steps
My virtual sessions offer the privacy and flexibility you deserve, with early morning, evening, and weekend appointments available.
Don’t see a time that works? Email: Admin@onpartherapynyc.com !