Starting Therapy for the New Year: Everything You Need to Know About Finding the Right Fit

January can feel like you're emotionally hungover even if you didn't drink. The new year sits at this weird intersection of hope and dread. On one hand, clean slate! Fresh start! Anything is possible! On the other hand, the same problems you had on December 31st are still there on January 1st, except now there's added pressure to do something about them.

But also? If you're actually struggling, if the New Year's anxiety is hitting different this time, or if you've been thinking "maybe this is the year I finally try therapy"—that's worth paying attention to. Sometimes the transition into January creates just enough space to realize you've been white-knuckling it for a while.

Why New Year's Anxiety Is Actually a Thing

From a psychological standpoint, New Year's triggers what we call "temporal landmarks"—moments in time that feel significant and make us evaluate our lives. Think birthdays, anniversaries, the first day of school. These landmarks can be motivating, but they can also shine a spotlight on the gap between where we are and where we think we should be.

Add in the fact that January is cold, dark (hello seasonal affective patterns), financially stressful after holiday spending, and socially quieter after weeks of family intensity, and you've got a perfect storm for feeling... off.

Some signs that New Year's anxiety might be affecting you:

• Scrolling through social media feels actively painful because everyone else seems to have their shit figured out

• You made resolutions but can't shake the feeling that you'll fail at them (again)

• You're experiencing physical symptoms like trouble sleeping, changes in appetite, or that tight feeling in your chest

• You're avoiding making plans or commitments because the future feels overwhelming

• You're comparing this January to last January and feeling like you haven't made enough progress

If any of this resonates, first: you're not alone. Second: this might be a good time to actually do something about it, not because you're "supposed to" in the New Year, but because you deserve to feel better.

Want tools for managing anxiety that actually work? Sign up for my newsletter and get instant access to a 5-minute grounding practice that helps when your brain is spiraling. No fluff, just practical techniques you can use immediately.

What New Year's Therapy Actually Looks Like (No, You Don't Need to Be in Crisis)

The best time to start therapy isn't when everything is falling apart. It's when you notice patterns you want to change, when you're dealing with something that keeps showing up, or when you want to grow but don't quite know how to get there.

Here's what bringing "New Year stuff" into therapy might actually address:

The Perfectionism-Anxiety Loop: You set high standards (because that's how you've succeeded at everything else), then beat yourself up when you can't maintain them, which creates more anxiety, which makes it harder to actually do the things, which confirms your fear that you're not capable. Therapy helps you interrupt this cycle and build a different relationship with achievement.

Relationship Confusion: Whether you're navigating a situationship that's been going nowhere for six months, trying to figure out if your partner is actually right for you, or dealing with the emotional whiplash of modern dating, therapy gives you space to untangle what you actually want versus what you think you should want.

Career Transition Stress: Maybe you're up for partner at your firm, maybe you're realizing the corporate ladder isn't what you thought it would be, or maybe you're successful by every external measure but feel empty. These transitions are disorienting, and having someone help you navigate them makes a real difference.

The "I Should Be Happier" Feeling: You've checked all the boxes- good job, nice apartment, solid friend group, regular workout routine. So why do you still feel anxious, unfulfilled, or like you're performing a version of yourself rather than actually being yourself? This is one of the most common things high-achieving women bring to therapy, and it's incredibly valid.

New Year's Therapy Activities and Frameworks You Can Try Today

While working with a therapist gives you personalized support, some frameworks can help you start shifting how you're experiencing this transitional time.

The Facts vs. Feelings Practice

Your brain loves to present feelings as facts. "I'm behind in life" feels true when you're anxious, but is it actually factual? This practice helps you separate the two:

1. Write down the anxious thought (example: "I'm failing at adulting")

2. Identify the feeling (anxiety, shame, inadequacy)

3. List only the verifiable facts (example: "I'm 28. I haven't bought a house yet. My college roommate just got engaged.")

4. Notice the gap between the feeling and the facts

Usually, the facts are way less catastrophic than the feeling suggests. This doesn't make the feeling invalid, but it does give you perspective.

The 3-3-3 Rule for Anxiety

When New Year's anxiety hits and your thoughts are spiraling, this grounding technique interrupts the loop:

• Name 3 things you can see

• Name 3 sounds you can hear

• Move 3 parts of your body

It sounds almost too simple, but it works because anxiety pulls you into your head and this brings you back into your body and the present moment.

The 5-5-5 Rule for Decision Anxiety

Struggling with a decision (Should I stay in this relationship? Should I quit my job? Should I move cities?):

• Will this matter in 5 minutes? (Probably yes)

• Will this matter in 5 months? (Maybe)

• Will this matter in 5 years? (This is the real question)

This doesn't make hard decisions easy, but it does help you calibrate how much mental energy to spend on them.

The "What Would I Tell My Best Friend?" Reframe

Notice how much harsher you are with yourself than you'd ever be with someone you love? When you're spiraling about not being where you should be, ask yourself: if your best friend came to you with this exact situation, what would you tell her?

Then try extending yourself that same compassion. Not as toxic positivity, not as letting yourself off the hook, but as basic human kindness.

How to Actually Find a Therapist for New Year Mental Health Goals

Okay, so you've decided you want to try therapy. Now what? The process of finding a therapist can feel overwhelming, especially when you're already anxious. Here's how to navigate it without adding another layer of stress.

What to Look for in a Therapist

Not all therapists are the same, and finding the right fit matters more than you might think. Here's what to consider:

Specialization: If you're dealing with New Year's anxiety specifically, you want someone who specializes in anxiety treatment, perfectionism, or life transitions. Someone who works primarily with couples or addiction might be great at what they do, but they're not necessarily the right fit for what you're experiencing.

Approach: Different therapists use different methods. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) is great for anxiety and changing thought patterns. Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) teaches concrete skills for managing intense emotions. Mindfulness-based approaches help you build awareness and presence. Most good therapists integrate multiple approaches, but it's worth asking what their framework is.

Demographics and Lived Experience: Sometimes it matters that your therapist gets certain aspects of your life without you having to explain them. If you're a woman in finance, working with someone who understands that specific pressure cooker might make a real difference.

Logistics: Do they have availability that works with your schedule? Are they licensed in your state (this matters for virtual therapy)? These practical considerations determine whether you can actually sustain therapy long-term.

The Insurance Question: In-Network vs. Out-of-Network

How Out-of-Network Reimbursement Actually Works

Most PPO insurance plans include out-of-network mental health benefits. This means you pay your therapist directly, then submit a receipt (called a superbill) to your insurance company, and they reimburse you for a percentage of the session cost.

The reimbursement rate varies by plan, but many clients receive 60-100% of the session fee back. So a $250 session might actually cost you $50-$100 out of pocket after reimbursement.

The catch is that navigating this process can be confusing. I aim to simplify this process! My practice checks your out-of-network benefits and estimates your reimbursement rate, then I handle submitting claims on your behalf.

If you're based in NY, NJ, MA, FL, or SC and ready to work with a therapist who specializes in anxiety, perfectionism, and relationship dynamics for high-achieving women, schedule a free consultation call to see if we're a good fit. Sessions are $220-$260, and I can help you navigate the out-of-network reimbursement process.

Questions to Ask in a Consultation Call

Most therapists offer a free 15-20 minute consultation before you commit to working together. This isn't just for them to screen you—it's for you to screen them. Here's what to ask:

• What's your approach to working with anxiety/perfectionism/relationship issues? (Whatever your specific concern is)

• What does a typical session look like with you?

• How do you measure progress?

• What's your availability and cancellation policy?

• How do you handle out-of-network insurance reimbursement?

Pay attention not just to their answers, but to how you feel talking to them. Do you feel heard? Can you imagine being honest with this person? Therapy requires vulnerability, so the vibe check matters.

Is It Normal to Feel Emotional on New Year's Eve?

Absolutely. In fact, it would be weirder if you didn't feel something.

New Year's Eve is set up to be this peak emotional experience—you're supposed to celebrate, reflect, feel hopeful, maybe make out with someone at midnight, and wake up ready to become your best self. That's a lot of pressure for one night.

But here's what actually happens for a lot of people: you feel reflective about the year that's ending (sometimes sad, sometimes grateful, often both), anxious about the year ahead, nostalgic about past New Year's Eves, and hyperaware of who you're with or not with. Add alcohol, late nights, and the general chaos of the holiday season, and you've got a recipe for big feelings.

Some people cry on New Year's. Some people feel lonely even in a room full of people. Some people feel this crushing pressure to have the "perfect" night and then feel let down when it's just... a night.

All of this is normal. The cultural mythology around New Year's Eve doesn't match most people's actual experience, and that gap can make you feel like you're doing it wrong. You're not.

Why New Year's Eve Specifically Triggers Anxiety

New Year's Eve forces you to take stock. It's one of those temporal landmarks we talked about earlier—a built-in moment to look back and look ahead. And if the year didn't go how you planned, or if you're not where you thought you'd be, that reflection can sting.

There's also something called "anticipatory anxiety" that kicks in around New Year's. Your brain is trying to predict and control what's coming, which is impossible, so it just spins out instead. The unknown of a whole new year ahead can feel destabilizing, especially if you're already anxious.

And socially, New Year's Eve has this weird way of highlighting relationship status. If you're single and didn't want to be, if you're in a situationship that's going nowhere, if you're questioning your relationship, or if you're missing someone you used to spend New Year's with—all of that gets amplified on December 31st.

What Actually Helps When You're Feeling Emotional on New Year's

Permission to not make it a big deal. You don't have to go to the party, you don't have to drink champagne, you don't have to make resolutions, and you don't have to force yourself to feel celebratory if you don't.

Sometimes the most radical thing you can do is acknowledge that you're feeling tender and give yourself space for that. Order takeout, watch something comforting, text a friend who gets it, or write out what you're feeling without judgment.

If you're spiraling, try the grounding techniques we talked about earlier. And if you're noticing that the emotional intensity around New Year's is part of a bigger pattern—if you've been struggling with anxiety or feeling off for a while—that's information worth paying attention to.

How to Get Over New Year Anxiety: What Actually Works

Let's be real: you can't just "get over" anxiety by thinking positive thoughts or doing a few deep breaths. If it were that simple, you would have figured it out already.

But you can learn to work with anxiety differently, to reduce its intensity and frequency, and to stop letting it run your life. Here's what actually helps.

Understand What Your Anxiety Is Trying to Do

Anxiety isn't random, and it's not a character flaw. It's your nervous system trying to protect you from perceived threats. The problem is that your nervous system doesn't know the difference between actual danger (like a car swerving into your lane) and social/emotional danger (like the possibility of failing or being rejected or not being enough).

So it treats the thought "what if I don't achieve my goals this year" the same way it treats "what if that's a bear in the woods"—with a full stress response.

Once you understand that anxiety is your brain trying to keep you safe (even when you're not actually in danger), you can start responding to it differently. Instead of fighting it or feeling broken because you have it, you can acknowledge it and then choose how to respond.

The Strategies That Actually Work for New Year's Anxiety

1. Externalize the Anxiety

When you're anxious, it feels like the anxiety IS you. But it's not. It's something you're experiencing, not something you are. Try talking to your anxiety like it's a separate entity: "I hear you, anxiety. You're worried about the future. That makes sense. But we're actually safe right now."

This sounds weird, but it creates just enough distance to give you back some agency.

2. Set Boundaries with Your Own Brain

If you notice your brain spiraling about all the ways you might fail this year, you can actually set a boundary: "I'm not doing this right now. If you still need to worry about this in an hour, we can come back to it."

Then redirect your attention to something concrete and present. Not as avoidance, but as a deliberate choice about what deserves your mental energy right now.

3. Build a Different Relationship with "Should"

Notice how much of New Year's anxiety is driven by "should"? You should have accomplished more last year. You should be excited about the new year. You should have your life more figured out by now.

Every time you notice a "should," get curious: according to who? Where did I learn this rule? Is it actually true? What would happen if I let go of this expectation?

This isn't about lowering your standards or giving up on growth. It's about questioning whether the standards you're holding yourself to are actually serving you or just making you anxious.

4. Practice the Pause

When anxiety hits, there's usually a moment before you react where you can choose how to respond. Most of us skip right over this moment because we're so used to our anxiety patterns.

But if you can catch yourself in that split second, you can ask: "What do I actually need right now?" Sometimes it's reassurance, sometimes it's distraction, sometimes it's just acknowledgment that this feels hard.

The pause gives you options. Without it, you're just running your usual anxiety script.

5. Get Your Body Involved

Anxiety lives in your body as much as your mind. You can't think your way out of it, but you can move your way through it. This doesn't mean you have to go to the gym (though movement helps)—it means doing something that discharges the physical energy of anxiety.

Go for a walk. Dance badly to one song. Do 20 jumping jacks. Splash cold water on your face. Anything that reminds your nervous system that you're here, you're present, and you're not actually in danger.

When New Year's Anxiety Might Be More Than Just Holiday Stress

Sometimes what feels like "New Year's anxiety" is actually a signal that you've been struggling with anxiety more broadly and the transition into January is just highlighting it.

If you're noticing any of these, it might be time to talk to someone:

• Anxiety that interferes with your daily functioning (work, relationships, basic tasks)

• Physical symptoms that won't go away (headaches, digestive issues, insomnia)

• Avoidance patterns that are limiting your life

• Feeling constantly on edge or unable to relax

• Intrusive thoughts that you can't shut off

• Using substances or other behaviors to manage anxiety in ways that concern you

You don't have to wait until it's unbearable to get support. In fact, addressing anxiety before it completely takes over is way more effective than waiting until you're in crisis.

Ready to work on anxiety with someone who actually gets the specific pressures of being a high-achieving woman trying to do all the things? Schedule a free consultation to see if therapy is right for you. I work with clients in NY, NJ, MA, FL, and SC, and sessions are covered by most out-of-network insurance benefits.

About the Author

Brianna is a Licensed Clinical Mental Health Counselor (LCMHC) and founder of On Par Therapy, a boutique virtual practice serving high-achieving women across five states. She specializes in anxiety, perfectionism, and burnout using evidence-based approaches, including CBT, DBT, and Motivational Interviewing. Her work has been featured in Vogue, Forbes, Time, and Bustle.

Brianna works with clients located in New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, Florida, and South Carolina.

Schedule an introduction call here.